Guacamelee is deceptively dull. The combat especially felt like a chore to be overcome. I played through the first one, definitely not interested in going back for a second helping.
I blasted through RDR2 in like a week and a half, and it was fucking amazing. That being said, after the credits rolled I had zero desire to continue. There's plenty of stuff I could still do, but I always end up at the same conclusion with R*'s games, and that is to say, once the story is over, the world feels completely dead to me.
Now I'm chugging through Digimon Story Cyber Sleuth Hacker's Memory, and as much of a shameless recycling it is of the previous game, I'm still enjoying it.