Half Light -Low.
I actually BOUGHT this MP3. Not cause I felt like suddenly not supporting piracy of music, but to to make sure I got the right song. For some reason this song is really hard to find and there isn't much out there about it. But I loved it and I didn't want to buy the rest of the album it came off of (Mothman Prophecies) just for this one song. So I just went ahead and threw down the 99 cents at Amazon. I've also seen the video for this song and it has such a surreal creep vibe that I think that's half the reason I like it so much.
Edit: So I love that this song is listed as featuring Indrid Cold. Which is kinda funny since Indrid Cold was suppose to be a creature sighted around the same time and place as the Mothman, and is known as a "Grinning Man".