I'm keeping 3 and Resurrection in my queue, mind you, but it's still balls.
3 was ok...Resurrection not so much.
I'm not so much knocking the movies in that sentence, I was still harping on about how Hicks and Newt being dead sucks and makes me anticipate the last two films less. It's been so long since I've seen either film, I don't remember how I liked them. Although I think my opinion was probably in-line with yours.
And to reiterate, I think in a novel or comic or some other medium, maybe explaining those things would work. (I've only seen the films so I don't know what's been covered elsewhere.) I don't see the possibilities in a whole film based on that one premise. Maybe they should do an Animatrix kinda thing with Alien and Predator, where we get to see a bunch of short films on various stories in that universe. That could be pretty cool, providing they don't wander into Matrix-level pretention.
Also, since I saw Alien again today with the commentary, I'm disturbed at how sexualized they imagined the film to be in regards to the treatment of women. I wouldn't mind it if it also applies to the men but it doesn't. Xenomorphs apparently dig human gals. The alien is constantly referenced to checking out the women. At one point, Scott and Weaver talk about how they wanted to do a scene where the alien looks in fascination at Ripley's
bony ass "pink body". And Ian Holm-bot's attack on Ripley with the magazines in her mouth is a rape since, to parphrase, "he doesn't have that part". FTW. Ew. (And why would they make an otherwise perfect human replica w/o a wang anyway?)
I'm also annoyed the commentary never explained why Ian Holm-bot flipped out. It just seemed to come out of nowhere. He had a directive to return with the xenomorph. Did his directive say "if not possible, rape nearest female crew member"?